Blade Spells

[Draven]

After reviewing the rules, I have a question.

Referencing Blade Spells, Page 98 -

Identical effects do not stack. No person
may have a second copy of the same effect active
at the same time, whether caused by a spell
or alchemy or any other source. Therefore, you
cannot have both a Poison Shield active from a
spell and a Poison Shield active from an elixir.
You can, however, have one of each Blade
spell active, as well as one of each reversible
spell (such as a Chaos Blade and an Earth
Blade) since they are separate effects.

So, I can see how I can have a Magic Blade, a Chaos Blade, and an Earth Blade. But can I have two Elemental Blades if they are of a separate element, as the term "identical effects" are ambiguous? If one is providing me with flame, and I cast another and direct it to provide me ice, those are identical in the sense they're both Elemental Blades, but not identical in the sense they're providing me with separate elements.

 

[jpariury]

The effect is "Elemental Blade", both in name and in the incant. The choosing of what element is done by the recipient. For Earth Blade and Chaos Blade, they are distinct effects, both in name and in the incant, as is Magic Blade. You could have one Elemental Blade, one Magic Blade, one Earth Blade, and one Chaos Blade. You could not have one Elemental Blade in which you choose to swing with an Ice carrier, and another Elemental Blade in which you choose to swing with a Stone carrier.