Question: Is this Accurate?

Dr_Chill

Fighter
All,

I was reading through a trade journal and would like some validation one way or the other.

http://www.worldatwork.org/waw/adimLink?id=49438

After reading the above article, do you feel that is it off base? I am on the cusp between X-ers and "millenials" and am curious as to a front-line opinion from any "millenials" out there.

-Ryan
 
I'm older than the group mentioned, but here is my 2 cents.

It's a poll & people will say what they think will make them feel/look good. 'My job is meaningful' sounds great when compared with 'How much will I make?'
There will be people that want their job to be meaningful over pay, but if it means they are eating Top Ramen 3x per day or being able to have a good meal...the masses tend to wander towards that good meal.
 
I would think this is accurate. I am right on the edge (1980).

The hiring managers perceptions are likely being heavily influenced by the current material culture we live in. When education is marketed as a means to get a larger salary as opposed to a means to gain "meaningful employment" what else are they supposed to think?

If you move past that initial statement the rest of the stats are pretty much spot on. I have been in several organizations throughout my career, and in general my peers tend to be almost INSISTENT on changing existing systems. Anything that was in place before their arrival is considered inefficient and antiquated.

The statistics regarding the ability to communicate professionally and "soft skills" like networking go hand in hand. Many of my peers have lost the ability to write professionally, many more lack the ability to communicate professionally in person. Some don't even see the value in it saying, "I'm not here to kiss up to anyone... I just want to do my job."

What do you think?

Stephen
 
RiddickDale said:
The statistics regarding the ability to communicate professionally and "soft skills" like networking go hand in hand. Many of my peers have lost the ability to write professionally, many more lack the ability to communicate professionally in person. Some don't even see the value in it saying, "I'm not here to kiss up to anyone... I just want to do my job."

What do you think?

Stephen

This is sadly accurate. The complete and utter lack of professional communication skills - something that was stressed to me starting in high school - is depressing. I see people who I know are not stupid come across as exactly that because they write emails that look like they were typed on the train - and they probably were. They're not even checking for simple things like grammar and spelling, nevermind paying attention to tone, appropriate phrasing etc. I should never receive a work email that starts with "Hey, ..." Yet I do, all the time.

People forget that written word is binding, whether it's a contract that you spent three weeks writing, or the cranky email you fired off in three minutes from your blackberry. And because you can't discern things like tone of voice or body language through print, the words you choose are even more critical.
 
Agreed.

I actually find it ironic. It's message boards like these that are "part of the problem." Many youth get into these boards because they are a sports fan, or play WoW, etc. With no real guidance a lot of them crowdsource their language skills into the toilet.

There are always exceptions of course, but it is a grim little piece of commentary on the the state of communication right now.

<edited to fix a spelling error... :lol:>
 
It's not just the Millennials. I got a text from my mom a few days back saying "Will u b at the shower 2moro?" This stuff is infectious. :(
 
Toddo said:
It's not just the Millennials. I got a text from my mom a few days back saying "Will u b at the shower 2moro?" This stuff is infectious. :(

I'm a bit more open to making exceptions for texting and Twitter.... because there are practical limitations on how many characters you can use.

It is when those shortcuts find their way into less restricted forms of communication that I get worried.
 
There's a fair disparity between groups of Millennials with regards to communications ability. And, by the by, it's absolutely strange to see conversations I constantly have professionally showing up on these forums... my worlds are mixing!

The culture gap between incoming Millennial workers and their managers is largely responsible for this. Many in this group did not receive adequate coaching and preparation for a professional workplace during their internship experiences throughout college, or while tending bar to pay their bills. Very few managers want to offer that basic professional coaching in a supportive fashion for incoming young workers.

Some of this is actually our generation's fault (Xers) - having brought a largely casual and friendly atmosphere into the workplace culture (when did casual Fridays turn into casual Mondays through Thursdays as well? Yup, that was us), as the managers most interns are working with are Gen X, and are not coaching them on formal professionalism but rather choosing often to "let things slide" since they're so young, just an intern, well-intended, etc. Coachable moments become jokes rather than teaching opportunities.

On a positive note, however, there are large percentages of Millennials that are incredibly hard-working, communicate professionally, and are looking to improve their generation and the workplace at large. I get to work with those students, primarily, and they're great. :)
 
Well, I can say for myself that I have always valued doing work I found meaningful very highly. With the birth of my second child, however, I have had to acknowledge that a salary capable of meeting my minimum standards of living for my whole family and allowing me to save something each month is far more important a measure than anything like it was when I was in college and just looking after myself.
 
Back
Top