I'm also using a badger, though I don't recall what model and I also got it at Michael's. Got my compressor there too.
I use ben nye for my makeup, along with their liquid make-up thinner. Mine stays on all weekend without worry... even in a light rain.
What I would recommend doing is signing up for the Michael's ad fliers. They put out 40% off coupons every now and then. Grab one when you have one of those.