So not everything was perfect, but its the first game, and there were several points I had fun. And the people are fun and I prefer to focus on the positives rather than not. So first I'll put down the few things I was disappointed with, but then spend longer on the things I enjoyed.
I guess the largest thing that bothered me was I felt a little lack of plot. While there was some closure to be able to go and destroy the entire cobalt camp finally at the end I would have liked to perhaps meet a noble, or maybe just found some NPC's who had a little bit more authority and could have told us a little bit more about the land. That said there were some, and I appreciated Chris's fellow who came out later in the day and Invested people in the two circles so we could ID stuff and could have res'ed people if that had had to have happened.
Probably the most fun for me was getting a taste of what "being the celestial" guy and what it would be like to run a Celestial CoP would be like towards the end of the day. That's something that I've always been interested in, and it finally made sense for my character to do that.
Reading and giving folks advice on ritual scrolls was a big one as well. i really enjoyed doing "favors" like reading a scroll and writing a sign for the bar keeper for the food that I ate that day. Thanks Ryan!
I also like all the different new characters that I saw several people play, and how well people got into them. While there were some times when PC's sitting around lapsed into OOG chat the majority of the time I felt like people were really RP'ing very well. John although our characters seem to have a little bit of a dis-connect going OOG I was laughing so hard at your "baby" mystic wood elf! I really hope I didn't give him an everlasting fear of Dark Elves... :?
I also enjoyed the final battle with the cobalds, I'll admit I'm a combat guy and I enjoyed watching everyone go at it. Plus it was fun to step forwards and "take down" two lines of cobalds. The second time it was really cool when I stepped in front of the fighter line and a javlin comes flying at me to have two Two Handed swords swing from behind me and take it out of the air. Then proceed to leave everything with smoking boots, and after taking down all the cobalds turn around and watch people picking up the pieces.
Also, although I sort of lost a fair amount of value in Potions and other items, I kind of enjoyed setting off the explosive treasure trap and just "going boom"!
Lastly I was amazed at the fair look distribution between the entire town at the end. In all the Alliance events I have played at I have never seen such a fair split of everything, and that includes the mini auction which was pretty fun. Thanks Paul for heading that up with your Hobling! It was pretty cool that at the end practically every adventure in town received a cut of like 2 gold as well as a potion for their part in the town battle. For those newer or lower level folks out there I've been in your place not having the money to bid yet, but believe me you'll get there and having lots of coin from being bought out by the "richer" older adventures can feel fun as well.
Overall a fun time and I really enjoyed hanging out with the folks I hung out with. Paige and Sam, great to see you! And Dave I look forward to working up my alt and hopefully making more games.