Since Vengeance is a Carrier as per:
Could plot have Rawr the monster who is really nasty that swings 30 Vengeance, and thus when the blows hit a persons body it is unavoidable damage?
viewtopic.php?f=98&t=11153The scroll specifically states that this special case is covered as follows:
"Earth/Chaos type Vengeance (as Vengeance but only creatures vulnerable to the appropriate Energy take damage or effect from this ability)."
Thus, the extra "Earth" or "Chaos" modifier does not work as a normal carrier (since Vengeance is itself a carrier), but merely informs the victim that they are only affected if they are normally vulnerable to that type of damage. Since two carriers are not normally allowed, consider this just like the scroll says - it's a Vengeance (unresistable damage) that only affects things which take a particular type of damage.
-Bryan Gregory
ARC
Could plot have Rawr the monster who is really nasty that swings 30 Vengeance, and thus when the blows hit a persons body it is unavoidable damage?