Squire Zanabanath - The Emerald Archer and his band have openly declared themselves brigands. They have robbed and attacked not only officers entrusted with keeping the peace but merchants who are just plying their trade, and have taken as their goal overthrow of the popularly supported government. They cited the plight of the people as their motivation, and for that I have respect, but that does not sanction a haphazard, armed insurrection. Civil war is no solution.
Assume they succeed, Regent Buchanon is ousted, killed, or exiled. What then? Will a ragtag band of guerillas, farmers, and soldiers be able to rebuild the provinces the Regent oversees? How will they react when the rest of Wayside responds to their attack with their own forces? How do they fight Arbor? When all supplies from all the Guilds are routed out of Buckland and New Buckland, how will the people fare? Who will protect them from external threats, pirates, profiteers, other internally developed "freedom forces"? Who will regulate trade, ensure the roads are kept clear, clean, safe, and in repair? Who will safeguard those who can't protect themselves?
If the Emerald Archer can somehow overcome all these obstacles and creates a sovereign nation - as I would have to believe Arbor would never allow one of their Regents to be so violently exiled without summary expulsion of the rebellious state - how would this new kingdom fare? How will the rest of Wayside live when such a strategically important region secedes? Suddenly, the entire center of the continent is teetering and predicated on the actions of a brigand. How will Wayside survive such an obvious blow to their sovereignty? How will Terna survive such a power vaccum?
The Emerald Archer is a traitor. Not only our Regent but the council of Regents and the entirety of the Guildmasters have called for his removal. Would you so blithely disobey an order from King Daefell? Would you so easily support a man looking to overthrow him? His Dukes? His soldiers?
If his claims are legitimate, they would not fall on deaf ears. In Briarpass alone, there are scores who would flock to his support in the Council Chambers. If a Regent is acting inappropriately, there are structures and resources in place to right the wrongs. Wayside has survived other such impediments without a coup d'etat.
I have outlined, briefly, my rejection of his acts. Squire, how do you defend him and his actions?
Master Dramthin Hartsboon
Keeper of the Tainted Grove