Thorpe,
I know when our heads meet things tend to fall in to what amounts to a personal arguement and I'd like to avoid that. It seems you hold a unique view of my presence. I have been traveling to Wayside for the vast majority of the previous year. I was unable to make two market days as my duties in alboria do not always allow me to travel. This was apparently the two market days that you started to make your presence known. As you can imagine, from my point of view it seems that you are the recent comer, but I am willing to consider that perhaps that view is wrong, perhaps the 5 market days I did not see you in the lands were simply because you were busy elsewhere and that your sporadic presence predates mine.
More importantly, while I think your proposals on how to configure the towns ruling council are well intentioned, I think they reflect poorly on your understanding of the people who live in town. Surely they are not all transients, even if I could still be considered one. The problem in my eyes is that your suggestions seem like carbon copies of places you've been previously. Not that emulating successful towns is in it self a back idea, but we must look closely on how well such a plan would work in our town.
Lets look at the options and try to keep this to a discussion about the merits. I have concerns about giving the guilds ownership and authority when they have shown no interest in such. So far the guilds have sent representatives to offer training/membership, and I believe them to be strong, honorable organizations, but from what I understand of their workings they don't wish to rule the town, their organizations are simply not invested in Wayside enough. That does not mean your idea does not hav merit, however I think we would be better served with a the election of a Magistrate. Such a person would have the power to pass judgement. Once such a ruling is made, I believe the town at large, and the Sheriff when he's in the area, will be able to take the nessasary steps. Such a magistrate would solve our largest issue, by being able to pass judgement he or she would be able to end the endless discussion that tends to be the towns achilles heel.
You mention the great strength it takes to stand up and say what should be done. This strength is required because you must be able to see your idea assaulted, twisted and turned, and purified in the fires that are animated discussion. Often you must be willing to see your idea changed from its original form into something that can truely work. So while strength is nessasary, if you truely wish to accomplish things you must also be humble, or at least capable of keeping your pride in check.
Lurin,
Leader of the Earthen Fist